French Court on Uber and its Drivers

On Wednesday, the French Court of Cassation held that a relationship of subordination exists between Uber, a multi-national ride-hailing company, and its drivers. Uber has previously claimed that it is a freelance digital platform for self-employed drivers. However, the court held the opposite, reclassifying the relationship between Uber and its drivers as that of an employer and its employees.

The judgement was passed in an appeal filed by an ex-Uber Driver whose Uber Account was suspended definitely in 2017 after the Industrial Tribunal dismissed his appeal on account of no employer-employee relationship.

In the Press Release pertaining to the ruling, the Court of Cassation enunciated the criteria for self-employment and employment. It held that:

“The criteria for self-employment are due in particular to the possibility of constituting one’s own clientele, the freedom to set tariffs and the freedom to define the conditions for the performance of its service provision.

Conversely, within the framework of an employment contract, the link of subordination rests on the power of the employer to give instructions, to control their execution and to sanction non-compliance with the instructions given.”

Testing the criteria against the existing relationship between Uber and its Drivers, the court observed that neither the drivers choose their clientele nor do they set the charges. In fact, the destination of the rides is revealed only after the ride begins. The Court pointed out, that the conduct of the drivers is also monitored via ratings and cancellation rates. In view of the French Court, these factors render the status of Uber as a freelancer digital platform being only fictitious.

The interesting aspect of the ruling is that even though the court has reclassified the relationship between Uber and its drivers, it has not mandated the execution of employment contracts by Uber.

The enforcement of the judgment constituting the reclassification of Uber drivers as employees would invoke tax obligations on part of both the drivers and the company which were non-existent before. Further, the cost of drafting and execution of employment contracts would be another brunt to bear for Uber. The broader implication of the judgement would be on other businesses of the gig economy in France.

However, France is not the first country to pass such a ruling. The United Kingdom, a few states of the United States of America and Swiss Canton of Geneva have held similar rulings or laws set in place in the recent years.

Considering the growing Uber-Ola Industry in India, would such a change in Uber’s Model be viable for our economy and the affected parties per se?

CONTINUE READING

The case of Aruna Shanbaug that changed the Euthanasia laws...

0
It is my Belief that death is a friend to whom we should be grateful, for it frees us from the manifold ills which are our lot - Mahatma Gandhi. As human beings, out the umpteen desires that we have, one of them is definitely to have a peaceful death....

Justice D Y Chandrachud’s path-breaking Verdict in the Sabarimala Case of...

0
“Will the quest for equality and fraternity be denuded of its content where women continue to be treated as children of a lesser god in exercising their liberties in matters of belief, faith and worship? Will the pursuit of individual dignity be capable of being achieved if we deny...

After repealing section 377, its time to Legalise Same-Sex Marriage in...

0
A draconian, archaic law that criminalized homosexuality was struck down in a historic judgment given by the Supreme Court in 2018. Two years after the judgment, the LGBTQ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer) community has now sought legal recognition of their relationships. As the social stigmas surrounding the LGBTQ...

Modern Day Book Burning a.k.a Internet Shutdowns

0
The internet has become an indispensable element in our society for all the obvious reasons. For the majority of users, not a single day goes by where we don't 'need' the internet and the lack of a reliable and fast connection can feel paralyzing. An internet shutdown refers to...

Letter to UNHRC – Dr Kafeel Khan, Punished Because He’s Muslim

0
Kafeel Khan, a doctor by profession and a social activist has been targeted by Yogi Government since 2017, in 3 years he had been maliciously arrested 3 times & imprisoned for around 14 months on the false charges set up against him at many instances. Now he is absolved...

Prison Life In India and its Aftermath

0
Everyone prays to never see the bars of prison in their lifetime. Yet, as fickle as life is, it is quite hard to predict the future. It is in everyone’s benefit to know a little bit about prison life; for movies and cinemas do not do justice to the...